ALTERNATE REALITY, serving Chicago comic fandom since 1978  That's over 40 years of service!                                                                                                    We started at the Comicbook Emporium in February of 1978, Five & Dime Comics from 1983 to 1994 and Alternate Reality ever since, thats over 40 years of serving Chicago South Side Comic Fandom                                                                   SAVINGS! SERVICE! SELECTION! HISTORY! We have it all!

  COMIC REVIEWS
AT THE MOVIES
  KIDS CORNER REVIEWS
RASSLIN' REVIEWS
  REVIEWS HOME
REVIEW ARCHIVES
 
JUSTICE LEAGUE: RISE & FALL SPECIAL/GREEN ARROW #31
("The Fall of Green Arrow")

Comic Review by:
"Sweet" Dan Sweet
Writer:
J.T.Krul
Artist's:
GA #31-Diogenes Neves
JLA Special-Mike Mayhew, and Fabrizio Fiorentino, Federico Dallocchio
Shipped on:
JLA Special-031010
GA #31-031710
Publisher:
DC Comics
MSRP:
JLA Special-$3.99 each
GA #31-$2.99
(15% OFF during it's 1st Week of release only at Alternate Reality!)
“With Krul masterminding this entire ordeal it’s the author’s fresh perspective on how to deal with an old favorite that’s going to keep me coming back for the rest.”
"...a conservative is a liberal who has been mugged." -Anonymous

Let me start by saying that this is the first book with the words ‘Justice League’ in the title that I’ve read that hasn’t been written by James Robinson in quite a spell. I wasn’t on board with what the author was doing over in “Cry for Justice”, and yet I found myself embroiled in quite an intense internet-debate over what ended up transpiring in the series’ final issue. To say that the ‘net nearly cracked in half when the super-villain Prometheus destroyed Star City, and as such dropped a building on G.A.’s granddaughter, would be the mother of all understatement, and THEN the Emerald Archer fired a fatal shot that so many heroes failed to take before. Why didn’t I think any of this was as big a disgrace as any of my internet cohorts?

Krul gets right to work by recapping all the more relevant bits and pieces of Robinson’s ‘masterpiece’ in less than ten-pages, an amazing enough feat unless you consider the fact that all of the Arrows’ characterization came in the last two issues anyway. It almost seems like the whole point of Robinson’s work was about getting the two Arrows’ to the worst possible condition imaginable, one that would lead Ollie down a path many dare not tread, as judge, jury and executioner for the scum that crosses his path. By offering insight into Queen’s mindset when he recovered Roy’s daughter from the rubble, and subsequently what was going on in his head when he shot an arrow between Prometheus’s eyes, adds more depth to both aspects of the story, which can easily be written off as ‘shock-value’ in Robinson’s hands.

The story primarily revolves around Oliver Queen and his wife, Black Canary, as they make their way through what remains of their home, Star City, attempting to either help those in need, or harm those seeking to take advantage of the situation, depending on whose side you take. Dinah notices Ollie’s determination to dole out as much pain and suffering as he possibly can to anyone causing even the slightest amount of trouble, and though she doesn’t call him on it, she realizes everything he has to work through.

In the meanwhile a couple pairs of Leaguers bounce around to different locales, hoping to track down Prometheus, whom they don’t know is already skewered to a wall in his own hideout. Dick “I’m Batman now!” Grayson and fellow former-Titan Wally “I’m not the real Flash anymore!” West take on the blue armor-clad waste of time that is Razer, a perfect Flash villain, but not so hot against the heel of Batman’s Doc Martins. Hal Jordan and Barry “Eff-You Wally West!” Allen manage to track down Prometheus’s corpse, causing Hal to gasp in shock, proclaiming: “Ollie killed him!” To which Barry “I’ve only been back from the dead for ten whole minutes” Allen retorts, “NO…He Murdered him!” Dun-dun-DUN!

Cut back to Ollie and Dinah as they cross paths with the Electrocutioner, who for whatever idiotic, only-in-a-comic-book reason decided to hang around the town he just blew to shambles, and now has to get his ass kicked by a girl, and a guy dressed in green tights, no less. Once Electrocutioner is subdued, Ollie continues his assault relentlessly, despite the man lying battered and broken in front of him. At this point Dinah, G. A.’s wife and longtime friend, steps in, hoping to keep her husband from crossing a line he’s already long passed. When Flash and Green Lantern show up and confirm her suspicions Ollie is left with no other choice than pilfering a dead man’s possessions, and beating feet out of town.

The story continues directly in Green Arrow #31 where Krul keeps the momentum going. While Ollie makes his way through the rubble of Star City, still trying to wreak as much havoc in the hearts and minds of those who take advantage of any and everyone. He sets his sights, literally, on street thugs, thieves, and corrupt police (now under command of an even more corrupt Commander).

There are some really great character beats as Ollie weaves a tangled web of deceit, and rage amongst the people he considered the closest to him. His distaste for Barry Allen is brought to light, as well as his lack of respect for his wife, Dinah Lance, the Black Canary. His son, Connor, gets a guest shot, and even he voices his opinion on the Green Arrow-goes-the-way-of-the-Punisher scenario that seems to be playing out.

The last page shocker really threw me for a bit of a loop, and not because I’m a long-time G.A. fan, or anything of that sort, but I finally seemed to realize just what the “Fall” of Green Arrow might mean to some of the people who’ve fought beside him. While next week (or the week after) debuts the “Rise Of Arsenal”, other members of the Arrow clan see consequences of their actions play out in the ‘Fall’, and I’m surprised that this is only advertised as a two-part story, considering almost every DC big-wig touted Green Arrow as a character-to-watch in the coming year.

I’m stoked for the ‘Rise’ and ‘Fall’, although I’m seriously hoping that Roy isn’t transformed into a vengeance-seeking, pseudo-90’s, Image-style anti-hero; if they were to set G. A. on that path, I’d be all for it, simply because the character has had a long enough and tenuous record with fans, and sending the concept in a new direction would be very interesting. With Krul masterminding this entire ordeal it’s the author’s fresh perspective on how to deal with an old favorite that’s going to keep me coming back for the rest.
 

All Books/Characters pictured herein are © Copyright 2010 by their respective owners. No rights given or implied by Alternate Reality, Incorporated.

Reviews © 2010 Alternate Reality, Inc.

RECENT REVIEWS...

AVENGERS VS.AOA #1

" ..is the team destined to star in cross-over after cross-over, with no real growth, for ever and ever, and ever?" (DS)
O110 BOM

"“I believe (Marvel's) intention is to wash away the dark elements that have been plaguing their titles...”  (DS)
0210 BOM

"A book about a man who wears an American flag while fighting crime SHOULD touch on current political situations,” (DS)

RETURN TO TOP