WOLFMAN
(**1/2)-JIM RUTKOWSKI

"...a dark (as in underlit), dramatically inert romantic tragedy/horror film..."

Silver Bullets and Studio Ineptitude Killed the Wolf

(011824)  A last-minute director switch of Mark Romanek to Joe Johnston only 2-3 weeks before the beginning of principal production, three release date changes precipitated by reshoots and new visual effects, a new editor (Walter Murch) to reedit the film, and a double switch in composers (from Danny Elfman to another composer and back again to Elfman), all but doomed "The Wolfman," the big-screen remake of the 1941 Universal classic, to box office and critical failure. Call it, like the central, tragic character, “cursed,” but all the tinkering and re-tinkering has done nothing to elevate "The Wolfman" above the grim, murky, muddled, inert, unsatisfying result Universal executives (probably) recognized when postponed the release date several times.

Based on the 1941 Universal horror classic that introduced Lon Chaney, Jr., as the titular Wolfman, the remake takes the story back roughly half a century to Victorian England, 1891 to be exact, replacing Chaney, Jr. with Benicio Del Toro in the role of Lawrence Talbot, the “prodigal son” of a wealthy British family headed by Sir John Talbot (Anthony Hopkins). A well-regarded, well-traveled actor estranged from his father (due, we find out later, to a traumatic event in Lawrence’s childhood), Lawrence only returns home when he receives a letter from his brother’s fiancée, Gwen Conliffe (Emily Blunt). Lawrence’s brother, Ben (Simon Merrells), has disappeared without a trace.

Lawrence arrives at the estate, eager to help in finding Ben, but he’s too late. Searchers find Ben’s mangled body in a ravine, killed by a wild beast or a madman. Warned by his father not to venture outside during a full moon, a stubborn, recalcitrant Lawrence does exactly that, visiting a nearby gypsy encampment to find out more about his brother’s past. Xenophobic villagers also arrive at the encampment, blaming the gypsies’ dancing bear for Ben’s murder (and the murder of two other men). He arrives only minutes before the beast, a werewolf, attacks the encampment, indiscriminately slaughtering gypsies and villagers alike, and almost killing Lawrence.

The gypsies return an injured Lawrence back to the Talbot estate where Gwen tends to him as he recovers. A near-miraculous recovery, however, leads the villagers, including the parish priest, Reverend Fisk (Roger Frost), to suspect Lawrence of lycanthropy. Only the senior Talbot’s timely intervention saves Lawrence, but once the full moon arrives, the villagers are proven right and Lawrence-as-the-Wolfman goes on a killing spree. A Scotland Yard detective, Francis Aberline (Hugo Weaving), arrives in the village, hoping to apprehend or otherwise stop the murderer. Loosely based on the Scotland Yard detective that investigated the Jack the Ripper murders in London, Aberline is a classic example of a rational man faced with the irrational. He doesn’t believe in the supernatural, only the natural world, but his encounter with a transformed Lawrence radically changes his worldview.

Andrew Kevin Walker (Sleepy Hollow, 8MM, Se7en) and David Self (Road to Perdition, Thirteen Days, The Haunting) screenplay follows the general plot points and turns in Curt Siodmak’s original script, with a few key differences: magnifying the romantic subplot to add pathos and, presumably, increase demographic appeal; making the Aberline an important secondary character; a different reveal for the identity of the original werewolf/Wolfman; thanks to the reshoots and more production time, additional screen time for the Wolfman in the latter half of the film; and adds a climactic (if clichéd) fight between Wolfman I and Wolfman II (the better to make Lawrence more a more heroic, less tragic figure). The Wolfman also gives audiences a sequel-ready ending, but that’s being overly optimistic on Universal’s part.

With Johnston (the upcoming "
Captain America: 1st Avenger," "Jurassic Part III," "Honey, I Shrunk the Kids," "The Rocketeer") coming in only three weeks before principal photography, he obviously didn’t have a chance to rework the screenplay to his liking, but instead focused on post-production (and reshoots) to fill in gaps and, presumably, add tautness and tension. At least that was the goal. What Johnston ultimately delivered with the help of editor Walter Murch, production designer Rick Heinrichs, cinematographer Shelly Johnson, makeup artist Rick Baker (who based the Wolfman’s design on Jack Pierce’s makeup for the original film) and composer Danny Elfman is a dark (as in underlit dark), dramatically inert romantic tragedy/horror film that sadly will please neither genre fans or casual moviegoers.
 

Directed by:    Joe Johnston
Written by:    Screenplay by Andrew Kevin Walker, David Self.
 Based on the original 1940 film The Wolf Man
 by Curt Siodmak
Starring:    Benicio Del Toro, Anthony Hopkins, Emily Blunt
Released:    02/12/2010 (USA)
Length:    125 minutes
Rating:    Rated R for bloody horror, violence and gore.

THE WOLFMAN © 2010 Universal Pictures
All Rights Reserved

Review © 2024 Alternate Reality, Inc.

  FORWARD INTO THE PAST
(aka "Old Reviews")
 

REVIEWS FROM THIS YEAR