TOXIC AVENGER
(***)-VITO CARLI

"...far from essential viewing, it is good enough to receive a mildly positive rating..."

Return to Tromaville (aka: "The Review")

(092525) This year marks the 40th Anniversary of the original Toxic Avenger film and it looks like this is shaping up to be the year of the Toxic Avenger revival. There are more than a few current comic series featuring him from Ahoy Comics. One of the titles ("Toxie Team Up") features the cult hero, teaming up with the Jesus Christ-the Jesus from Ahoy’s "Second Coming" intermittent comic series. The first issue of the old Marvel Comics Toxic Avenger series from 1991-92 recently went way up in price and is selling for over a hundred dollars on eBay. To add to this anniversary we have a new version of the Toxic Avenger on film and it is a satisfactory but not great remake of the eighties cult classic. 

The film has been in the news a lot because some theatre chains have reported that record amounts of people have been walking out of the theater (I don’t think the scene in which our hero defeats someone by urinating radioactive waste on someone helped.)  A similar thing happened during James Franco’s award-winning mountain movie, 127 Hours, which caused both walkouts and some people even reportedly vomited.  If anything, I was a bit disappointed because I found it a little tame and less transgressive than the original. But this version has the advantage of having better special effects and production values, plus a good cast that features actors I have actually heard of like Peter Dinklage, Elijah Wood, and Kevin Bacon.

This film, as with the original, was made by Troma, which is known for putting grade Z (which is much lower than B) exploitation films. Their films are so cheap that they make Roger Corman’s Masque of Red Death, which was considered very low budget at the time, look like Titanic. The New City rock critic, Ray Pride, famously once wrote that no amount of alcohol could make me give a Troma film a positive review. I like some of them, but the only one I truly loved was Tromeo and Juliet, a splatter punk version of the Shakespeare classic, which was written by James Gunn, yes-that Gunn from Superman. And it was narrated by Lemmy, the late leader of Motorhead, On the Tromeo VHS cover, it says it has “Body piercing, kinky sex, and dismemberment. All the things that made Shakespeare great.” Other Troma films, such as Sgt Kabukiman, Class of Nuke' em High, and Cat Girls in Heat, have some good moments in them as well. Many of these films can be screened for free on Tubi. My interview with Lloyd Kaufman,  who co-produced Tromeo, can be found on my website at Lloyd Kaufman Interview – ART INTERVIEWS and in the new book called Lloyd Kaufman Interviews, which is part of the Conversations with Filmmakers series, https://www.amazon.com/Lloyd-Kaufman-Interviews-Conversations-Filmmakers-ebook/dp/B0DTZ6Z1ZB.

In this remake, Peter Dinklage (
X-Men Days of Future Past and Avengers Infinity War) plays Winston (aka: "the Hero") a character who is decent, but he finds himself pushed around a lot. He works for an unscrupulous corporation BTH (aka: "Body Talk Health") that is knowingly exposing nearby citizens to toxic waste as a result of all the shortcuts they take to save money. At one point he witnesses some thugs hired by developers threatening harm to his neighbor and her cat unless she sells the feline to the corrupt corporation. He saves her cat, but his son criticizes him for not directly confronting the thugs and doing more. This seems unfair since the hoods are several feet taller than he is.

Eventually
Winston is involved in an industrial accident, which hideously deforms him but also gives him fast healing powers and superhuman strength. It transforms him onto the Toxic Avenger (played by British actress Luisa Guerreiro). Like the original story, "Toxie" is a misunderstood monster with a good heart and superpowers who fights evil in the town of St. Roma Village (aka: "Tromaville"). It's a blend of two genres: horror and superhero. In many ways it tells a tale similar to the origins of the Incredible Hulk and Swamp Thing, and in tone it is obviously influenced by early Marvel Comic stories. And like traditional heroes, Toxie also has a gadget he employs in crime fighting.  Where Captain America has his shield and Batman his bat-a-rang, Toxie has his trusty mop which he uses a weapon in fighting evil. Unlike the other heroes he likes to push it through people’s heads in battle to gloriously gory effect. These and other gore effects here are one reason the film was initially going to be released unrated, but finally given a much deserved "R" rating.

Kevin Bacon (
X-Men First Class and MaXXXine), gives a tasty scene-chewing performance as Bob Garbinger (aka: "the Villain"). He has a girlfriend who is dressed and filmed so she resembles Melania Trump. At one point in desperation, they both inject themselves with toxic waste and gain powers similar to Toxie, and they ultimately end up battling him and his sidekick in the climax. Elijah Wood plays Bob's brother Fritz (aka: "the Creepy Brother"), who is a bit more sympathetic and looks like the singer/playwright from Rocky Horror. He manages a rock group that doubles as thugs that look like Insane Clown Posse rip-off with one guy dressing as a chicken. Subtlety is intentionally not in the films round house and many of the characters are drawn either as corrupt or stupid or both, The films allusions to Trump and his Cabinet are obvious.

Like all super-hero films there is a post credit scene that is both odd and puzzling. Toxie appears in an instructional video, giving advice on how to best make grilled cheese sandwiches. The scene is interesting, but I am not quite sure why they decided to end the film this way. It's neither good nor bad, it adds nothing to the film and doesn't seem to promo a sequel-it's just bizarre. And perhaps that oddness is a commentary on the whole post credit phenomenon itself.

This new version was actually created two years ago in 2023, but it was shelved because the filmmakers had problems finding a distributor. It is just now coming out in theaters, and it has wide distribution for this type of film. The film was put out by Converse, who are known for successfully distributing profitable, cheap horror films. They previously found remarkable success putting out the movies in the "Terrifier" series, which I sort of liked, featuring a homicidal killer clown with supernatural powers that defy logic.  
 
The film has found an original and admirable way to get publicity. One of the story themes is to spotlight the plight of several poor characters who cannot afford to pay for health care. This theme is a purposeful story element in the film acting as a sort of reverse product placement. The makers of this film have pledged to give financially disadvantaged sick people a percentage of the profits up to five million dollars. The money will go to the non-profit Undue Medical Debt, an organization that leverages donations to purchase qualifying medical debt. For every one million they make at the box office they are committed to erasing an additional million in debt.

While the film is far from essential viewing, it is good enough to receive a mildly positive rating, and it would make a decent Svengoolie film (he has shown far worse films) assuming the gore effects were "cleaned up" (aka:cut) for television. Toxic Avenger is recommended, but mostly for fans of horror, superheroes, and cult movies, and only for viewers with strong stomachs.

 

Directed by:  Macon Blair
Written by:  Screenplay by Macon Blair. Based on the 1984
 film The Toxic Avenger by Lloyd Kaufman
Starring:    Peter Dinklage, Jacob Tremblay, Taylour Paige
Released:    08/29/2025 (USA)
Length:    103 minutes
Rating:    Rated R for strong violence and gore, language
 throughout, sexual references and brief graphic
 nudity
Available On:    At press time the film is available to rent or buy on
 Fandango at Home

For more writings by Vittorio Carli go to www.artinterviews.org and www.chicagopoetry.org. His
latest book "Tape Worm Salad with Olive Oil for Extra Flavor" is also available.
Email carlivit@gmail.com

See the film trailer of the Lee Groban movie directed by Nancy Bechtol featuring Vittorio Carli.
See https://youtu.be/tWQf-UruQw


The New Poetry Show:
Come to the New Poetry Show on the first Saturday of every month at
 Tangible Books in Bridgeport from 7:00pm-9:00pm at 3324 South Halsted.
Hosted by Vito Carli

-UPCOMING EVENTS-

October 4-Genesis Jimenez, Ivan Petryshyn, Sandra Santiago, and Bronmin Shumway

November 1 – Ivan Ramos, Nicholas Ravnikar and others

December 6 -Lynn Fitzgerald, Dan Godston, and Jennifer Karmin

For more information e-mail: carlivit@gmail.com for details.
 

 

TOXIC AVENGER © 2023 Troma Entertainment
All Rights Reserved

Review © 2025 Alternate Reality, Inc.

 

LAST TIME VITO  REVIEWED:
"Higest 2 Lowest"

     

NEXT TIME VITO REVIEWS:
"Together"