MARTY SUPREME
(****)-VITO CARLI

"...a terrific cinematic roller coaster ride..."

Chalamet's Supreme Performance of a Schmuck

(020826) Marty Supreme is a dizzying, fast-paced film about a young man who will do anything to achieve his dream of becoming a world-class ping-pong champion. The film creates this dizzying atmosphere through its masterful use of tight close-ups and long lenses. Like the recent Highest 2 Lowest and Caught Stealing, this film makes perfect use of its city setting and manages to fully capture the frantic energy of New York Life. Clocking in at 150 minutes, it seems shorter than the first hour of Wicked For Good or the first half hour of Captain America: Brave New World. The film was released late last year at Christmas time, and if I had seen it in time. I would’ve certainly put it on my Top 10 Films of 2025, or maybe even Top 5.

The Safdie brothers, Josuah and Benjamin, made big waves in the Indie film circuit with their debut film, Good Times (2017). They solidified their reputation with their magnificent second film, the Adam Sandler showcase, Uncut Gems (2019). Many critics and film commentators (including me) believe it got robbed at the Oscars. If Sandler were not so well known for his inane comedies, I think he at least would have been nominated for his performance in Gems. Marty Supreme is Josh Safdie’s first feature without his brother Ben. To date the film has been both a box-office and a critical success. Safdie successfully captures the Jewish New York community in the Lower East Side almost as well as Scorsese captured the Italian New York milieu in Mean Streets.

Marty Supreme is one of the most impressive sports-themed films I have seen in years, and it is comparable in quality to Chariots of Fire (1981) and Rocky (1976). But unlike Rocky, the main character, Marty is both admirable and despicable. Marty is an underdog struggling against tremendous odds, succeeding only through sheer force of will in a twisted version of the American dream. He destroys or harms everyone he meets, and is willing to cheat or use everyone around him. The film is by no means a traditional sports film, and it lacks most of the genre's defining characteristics. There are no Rocky-like montages of training routines or clear, triumphant feel-good wins in the film.

The film stars Timothy Chalamet, one of the hottest rising stars in Hollywood. He is probably best known for his films,
Interstellar (2014), Call Me by Your Name (2017), Dune (2021), Wonka (2023), Dune Part 2 (2024), and the film that contains his greatest performance, the Bob Dylan biopic, A Complete Unknown (2024). One of the many interesting things about the movie is that many of the characters look unglamorous and ethnic (mostly Jewish). Chalamet takes a big chance here, playing a mostly amoral character. Also, the filmmakers made him look unattractive, with imperfect teeth and horn-rimmed glasses. His character is loosely based on Marty “the needle” Reisman, a real tennis champ who by some accounts, was even a bigger conman and hustler than this fictional representation.

Marty Mauser is always scheming and scrounging for money, and he has dubious ideas about how to earn cash. He wants to drop balls from a blimp for a fake movie and sell orange ping-pong balls for some reason. In confrontation with his tormented financer, he loses control of the balls, which all drop to the floor, which goes along with him losing control of his dream or life, at least temporarily. The dropping of the orange balls is the most vivid single image in the film.

Marty is in simultaneous relationships with two women, and he treats neither one especially well. The two actresses playing the love interests for Marty are very good at portraying almost completely opposite characters. Gwyneth (Iron Man
and Shakespeare in Love) Paltrow is Kay, a bored, affluent, much older actress who has it all but will do anything to liven up her life. It’s not clear if he really cares for her or is just after her husband Milton’s money to fund his overseas sports excursions. In contrast, he has also been seeing his now-married high school girlfriend, Rachel (Odessa A’zion) for many years. She is a tragic working-class woman in a dead-end life and job, just trying to scrape by. Marty got her pregnant and refuses to take any responsibility for the baby. Both women may be on opposite sides of the social/economic fence, but both are also desperate and trapped in unsatisfying marriages while having an affair with Marty.

He chases after Kay ruthlessly until she gives in because she is surrounded by fakes and yes-men, and she finds his blunt honesty refreshing. I am sure he enjoys the company and sex, but he also has a big ulterior motive for seeing her. He wants to use her to get to her rich, bigoted husband, Milton, so he can convince him to sponsor his trip overseas to play a big match against his big rival the Japan’s champ Koto Endo. But the big catch is that Milton wants him to throw the match so he can make Koto a bigger hero to sell products. Will he go along with this? I am sure viewers will be as delighted with the results as I was.

The film is also filled to the brim with lively supporting performances and cameos, some by actors who have not been popular or seen much for years. Fran (The Nanny) Drescher is Marty’s long-suffering mom. The real-life controversial film and play director, David Mamet, plays a stage director here. It is also delightful and surprising to see performance artist/comedian Sandra Bernhard and alt hip-hop star "Tyler, the Creator" in small roles. The talented but largely forgotten director Abel Ferrara (The Bad Lieutenant) also appears as an unsavory and immoral character. My disastrous interview with him can be found at: Abel Ferrara Interview – ART INTERVIEWS)

Despite the fact that the film takes place in the 50's, it is filled with a generous selection of 1980s techno and post punk classics by Tears for Fears (Change and Everybody Wants to Rule the World), Alphaville (Forever Young), New Order (The Perfect Kiss), and Public Image Ltd. (My Song), as well as older songs. Interesting sidenote: when I lived in Bridgeport, I got to meet the Pil drummer, Martin Atkins, and my interview with him can be found at:
Martin Atkins Interview – ART INTERVIEWS

Although I liked it only slightly less than another carryover from last year: The Mastermind
Marty Supreme is a terrific cinematic roller coaster ride that features one of 2025’s most memorable lead characters and one of the best male performances. It makes most of the current releases look mindless, gutless, and forgettable in comparison.
 

Directed & Written by:    Josh Safdie
Starring:    Timothee Chalamet, Gwyneth Paltrow, Odessa
 A’zion
Released:    12/25/2025 (USA)
Length:    150 minutes
Rating:    Rated R for language throughout, some sexual
 content, nudity and some bloody scenes
Available On:    At press time, playing at selected theatres

For more writings by Vittorio Carli go to www.artinterviews.org and www.chicagopoetry.org. His latest book "Tape Worm Salad with Olive Oil for Extra Flavor" is also available.
Email carlivit@gmail.com

See the film trailer of the Lee Groban movie directed by Nancy Bechtol featuring Vittorio Carli.
See https://youtu.be/tWQf-UruQw

Upcoming features at the New Poetry Show:
Come to the New Poetry Show on the first Saturday of every month at Tangible Books in
Bridgeport from 7-9 at 3324 South Halsted.

Match 7- Special Chicago City College Instructors Show: Ana Arredondo, Paula Diaz, Bob Lawrence and Music by Peer Review Pending

April 4- Criage Lynette Althage, Clair Fluff Llewelyn and Kaytee Thurn


This is now a monthly show featuring Poetry/Spoken Word, some Music, Stand Up and Performance Art and hosted by Mister Carli.

For more information e-mail: carlivit@gmail.com for details.
 

MARTY SUPREME © 2025 A24
All Rights Reserved

Review © 2026 Alternate Reality, Inc.

 

LAST TIME VITO  REVIEWED:
"No Other Choice"

     

NEXT TIME VITO REVIEWS:
"TBA"