OBSESSION
(***˝)-VITO CARLI

"...the concept has rarely been done this well."

A Bold Take on the Classic Devil’s Bargain Tale

(072226) There are a few signs of box-office renewal that indicate the motion picture theatre business cannot be counted out just yet. There have been two recent films that have become massive surprise hits.  Both Borders and Obsession were made on comparatively low budgets and each was released with limited publicity. But they have been beating out most higher-profile releases, and they dominated the box office for weeks. Many of the viewers who are going to see Borders and Obsession, which have unknown directors and no big stars, were twenty-something's who usually stream their films. This is a great sign that there is a future in films and that alternatives to sequels, remakes, and franchise films can be highly profitable. Obsession was made for only $750,000, and so far, it has grossed over $442 million. In contrast, the massively hyped Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu cost over $165 million to produce and has made 344 million dollars. Obsession has a much more desirable cost to profitable ratio than Mandalorian, especially when you factor in the budget and publicity for both films.

Obsession is not particularly original, and it basically is a retread of the devil’s bargain story or an update of Faust or Bedazzled. The film also bears some similarity to the Buffy the Vampire Slayer episode, “The Wish,” in which the romantically unlucky Xander uses a supernatural totem to  make a wish to make himself irresistible to women. IIn these stories, someone makes a deal with a supernatural being and is granted one or more wishes, but the wishes are delivered in a way that leaves the person deeply unhappy-be careful what you wish for. The only difference here is that the protagonist never meets a demon; he merely makes the wish using a magical object. But the concept has rarely been done this well. 

Curry Barker is a little-known 26-year-old filmmaker who made a series of YouTube shorts before graduating to the found-footage film Milk and Serial (2024). Just from Obsession, you can tell he is a resourceful, economical, and efficient filmmaker, unusually skilled at orchestrating fright scenes and building suspense. Barker adds many twists and unexpected bits of character interplay that fill out the story and greatly elevate the film.

Obsession is filled with bright, fresh, and lively performances. Michael Johnson is reliable and steady in the role of Bear, and his character swiftly shifts from a quasi-likable protagonist to a despicable villain.  He basically serves as a straight man for the wigged-out antics of his romantic partner, Nikki (Inde Navarette).  Johnson appeared as Corey Bryant in the MTV series Teen Wolf (2015-2017), and she shows outstanding potential here,

Inde Navarette’s performance in the film is astonishingly well done and positively electrifying, with unexpected jarring highs and lows.  Of all the female performances this year, this one impressed and impacted me the most. Watching her is like spending an hour and a half on a great roller coaster ride. Inde is best known to comic fans for playing Sarah Cushing on Superman & Lois (2021–2024).

The rest of the supporting cast is also more than impressive. Cooper Tomlinson is best known for his previous collaboration with Cully Baker in Milk and Cereal (2024). Here he plays Bear’s manipulative, not always trustworthy friend.  Megan Lawless, who was in The Hate U Give (2018), plays another potential love interest to Bear, who, in most ways, would be a better romantic choice than Nikki.  Andy Richter, who is hard to recognize here, also shines here in a fun supporting role. He was previously perfect in the role of Conan O' Brien’s sidekick on NBC's Late Night, The Tonight Show, and Conan on TBS. He was also the star of the short-lived Fox television series Andy Richter Controls the Universe (2003).

In Obsession, Bear (Michael Johnston) is hopelessly smitten with his work friend Nikki (Inde Navarrette). But they work together at a video store, and she plans to quit, so he might not see her much in the future. We are very sympathetic towards him initially because he is very lonely and isolated, and he recently lost both his cat and grandmother. After he drives her home, Bear and Nikki have a heartfelt conversation.  She seems to suspect how he feels about her, and she probes him about it. He gets a chance to man up and proclaim his love, but he blows it because he prefers keeping things as they are rather than risk rocking the boat and perhaps losing her completely.

Bear uses a magic piece from a gift shop called a One Wish Willow to wish that Nikki will “love him more than anything else in the world.”  He notices a change in her behavior almost immediately, and they end up talking most of the night, and they have intercourse.  But he is not sure if this is because of the wish or because she had taken recreational  drugs, or perhaps she had a change of heart. Bear had previously been fairly likable and the film’s protagonist , but when he sleeps with Nikki, it’s as if she has been given a roofie,  so the scene has an unpleasant whiff of date rape sex. From then on, Nikki only thinks of him, but the intensity of her obsessive infatuation makes her commit weird, unpredictable, and dangerous actions. She first makes a shrine dedicated to his recently deceased cat and eventually, without his knowledge, even serves the cat to him as dinner. She also tapes the house exit shut so he will not leave her, and  she savagely beats a potential rival love interest.

Their immediate friends Ian (Cooper Tomlinson) and Sarah (Megan Lawless) interact with the new Nikki/Bear couple at a party and notice that she is acting irrationally and not like herself. In one of the weirdest and most effective sequences, she recites from a Hansel and Gretel text she is writing with long, disturbing passages that hint at incest. The friends also think that nothing about the new relationship adds up. Before Bear and Nikki got together, Nikki was having a fling with Ian, and she told several people that she only thought of Bear as a brother.  

The cinematographer, Taylor Clemmons, demonstrates his mastery of the medium through clever visual tricks. Nikki is sometimes shot so that her face is obscured or invisible in the shadows. This hints that she is largely absent, but the real Nikki is still hidden somewhere within the fake one, and the new one is, at best, an inferior, imperfect simulation or an imperfect copy of a real woman, lacking her humanity. She’s like an AI simulation of Nikki, lacking her essence and humanity.  At one point, when she is half asleep, Nikki tells him, “I’ve never been with you, Bear.”  At another point, Nikki pathetically pleads, “She’s asleep. Please kill me. It’s me.”

The whole cast and crew are worthy of praise, particularly the lead actress and director/writer, Curry Barker. Both are bursting with potential and obviously have promising futures ahead in the horror genre. Barker has taken a limited subject and minuscule budget and created one of the scariest and most disturbing films of the year.  It even compares well with such recent instant classics as Get Out (2017), Hereditary (2018), Midsommer (2019),
The Substance (2024), and Sinners (2025). This film was strong enough to be on my recent top 10 best films of the year so far list, and it was by far the best horror film I have seen this year.
 

Written & Directed by:    Curry Barker
Starring:    Michael Johnston, Inde Navarette, Cooper
 Tomlinson,
Released:    05/15/2026 (USA-wide)
Length:    109 minutes
Rating:    Rated R for strong bloody violence, grisly images,
 sexual content, brief graphic nudity, and pervasive
 language throughout
Available On:    Streaming on Peacock at press time

For more writings by Vittorio Carli go to www.artinterviews.org and www.chicagopoetry.org. His latest book "Tape Worm Salad with Olive Oil for Extra Flavor" is also available.
Email carlivit@gmail.com

See the film trailer of the Lee Groban movie directed by Nancy Bechtol featuring Vittorio Carli.
See https://youtu.be/tWQf-UruQw

 

Upcoming features at the New Poetry Show:
Come to the New Poetry Show on the first Saturday of every month at Tangible Books in
Bridgeport from 7-9 at 3324 South Halsted.

August 1rst-Heidie Belile, Janet Kuypers and others

September 5-Ixta Julietta, Eric Sirota, Donna Vorreyer, and Dan Weinberg


This is now a monthly show featuring Poetry/Spoken Word, some Music, Stand Up and Performance Art and hosted by Mister Carli.

For more information e-mail: carlivit@gmail.com for details.
 

OBSESSION © 2026 Capstone Pictures
All Rights Reserved

Review © 2026 Alternate Reality, Inc.

 

LAST TIME VITO  REVIEWED:
"Supergirl"

     

NEXT TIME VITO REVIEWS:
TBA